Not too long ago I saw a meme come across my social media feed stating, “90% of your life is a reflection of your habits”. It went on to say that your weight, health, financial stability, and happiness are up to you. While I value self-responsibility this post felt, well, privileged. I get the same feeling from spiritual gurus or self-help experts who turn around and gaslight followers who fail to find relief–the sufferer just didn’t try hard enough.
I get to witness the journeys and sufferings of people from all walks of life. Some individuals are depressed, despite their best efforts. Some struggle to maintain financial stability despite having two jobs, saving, and having a strong work ethic. Some suffer from health problems despite efforts to exercise and eat a balanced diet. I think it is important to realize that despite our best efforts suffering still happens. In fact, suffering is a universal human experience.
I attended a Survivor Celebration with 24 Hours in the Canyon Cancer Survivorship Center a few years back. Ethan Zohn spoke at the event. He won the TV show Survivor, he has run marathons, and he is a former professional soccer player. He also survived cancer twice. At the end of his talk someone asked a question about diet and exercise, preventative health. As I remember it Zohn stated, “Look, I did everything right and I got cancer twice”. I can only imagine how validating it was for everyone in the room to hear.
I think it is important to pause here and acknowledge that there is a benefit to blaming ourselves or others for suffering. If we can pin our suffering on something we did or did not do the world feels a little safer. We may feel more in control. But having witnessed the suffering of hundreds of people, it just doesn’t work that way. Suffering exists even when we do everything “right”.
Jennifer Baldwin in her book Trauma Sensitive Theology (2018) discusses the privilege of non-primary traumatization. She states, “The ability to allocate resources into areas of life other than survival and recovery is privilege”. Privilege happens when I assume that the differences in me and you are a result of my character or efforts; when I do not take into consideration all you have done to survive and recover. I might assume that I am less affected by a similar experience because of my own efforts, without considering the immensely important influence of support systems and resources that I had access to. I might assume that I am less affected by depression simply because I do all the “right” things. On the other side of this, I may blame myself when I suffer. If I am anxious, maybe I’m not doing it right, maybe I should pray more. I may assume I should be able to just think my way out of this. When this doesn’t work I feel more shame.
It is important to consider the privilege of wellness because it changes the way we treat ourselves and others in suffering. What if instead of judging, comparing, or minimizing someone’s experiences we instead assume that they are doing the best they can? That there is more to the story and perhaps they are surviving the best they know how? Perhaps all their energy is spent surviving, inhibiting other areas of growth.
I care about intentional interventions. I believe we do hold some responsibility for our wellness, but to assume that suffering is a lack of effort or intention is harmful. We know that healing is difficult and painful. We know that trauma may result in immobilization and secondary gains, making change risky. So, if you find yourself judging someone in their suffering, practice being the compassionate witness instead. Simply acknowledge the suffering and be kind. No rescuing or solutions are necessary. To love someone is to see them fully. Stay curious. Take care of you.
4 thoughts on “The Privilege of Wellness”
Who wrote you’re lead out? A singular or a collective?
I (Elizabeth Clark) wrote the entire blog. The quote circulated on social media and was written by an individual. I hope this answers your question.
A person’s thoughts create their results. So are they poor because of their thoughts, or are they poor because of external situations? Well, the situation, is also known as the circumstance and circumstances are not good nor are they bad they just are. Your thoughts are the start of your results. So is it a privilege to have a different thought? If you think so ok. Is it bad to be privileged? No! and I resent the very assumption that it is bad or that it is something we need to feel bad about. Simply
Now do some people suffer from depression? Oh yeah. Do some people have scarcity mindsets around money? Yeah but that is the cool thing about your thoughts. You can change your thoughts. It’s not easy and it takes just as much time as it takes to have thoughts that don’t serve you.
One of the biggest fallacies in today’s society is that we are able to be happy all the time! That is simply wrong. You are going to feel bad half of the time. Life is 50% pleasure and 50% pain. To avoid the pain is to keep the pain going. To resist suffering and resist discomfort is to stay in it. While if you take the pain as a part of life and you step through it. you see the pleasure is sweeter. So no you are going to battle with being depressed at times. And that is when you just have to sling it onto your shoulder and wear it like a heavy bag. It won’t stay the whole time and you have the pleasure to look forward to it.
The same goes for weight and health. More people live life fully because they are sick than those who are healthy. Who should we applaud? Sounds like the healthy should be comforted in that case because they aren’t living. they are just avoiding the pain in their life with all the buffering they are doing.
Yet you say assuming that suffering is because of a lack of effort is harmful, however, to believe the outside circumstances make your emotions seem even crueler than that. This is because you do have control over your emotions. To think you don’t have control is planting yourself into the seat of victimhood and being told you are always going to be in pain. Which is the worst lie?
Thank you for your thoughtful response. I agree with you. Thoughts and belief systems matter, and we address this often in therapy. In addition being happy all the time is not a realistic goal. Rather, our goal is to tolerate all feelings, including painful ones.
We aim here to balance the conversation. Privilege is not bad. It simply just exists. Assuming or placing responsibility where there is no power creates further shame, which immobilizes. We want to be discerning around what areas we can change–including our assumptions and our narratives and our behavior–and what areas we grieve. Many situations require both. Every individual’s story is complex. But we always aim to begin with compassion, then empower change. We have many other blogs that add more depth to this and speak to your feedback.
LikeLiked by 1 person